HillaryCare Provides Nothing
Posted in Public Affairs, Money Matters, Health, wordpress, Politics, campaign, Democrats, Clinton, disclosure, ethics, hillary on September 24th, 2007 by Stanford Matthews 
Hillary Rodham Clinton ‘officially’ released her health care plan about a week ago and has been touting it for longer than that. Her website is flooded with self-praise for the plan. One of the issues raised by critics of the plan has been cost. The Wall Street Journal’s HillaryCare’s New Clothes basically says the numbers don’t add up.
In HRC’s press release of what she calls the ‘Nevada Impact Report’ of her plan, the Kaiser Family Foundation is referenced repeatedly implying support of her claims. The editorial page from the Wall Street Journal referenced above does not agree her $110 billion is the end of the program cost and that the details are being withheld by her campaign. The Kaiser Family Foundation’s website provides some other numbers, presented below, that may be helpful as well that are not offered in the HRC press release.

The table above was taken from the Kaiser Family Foundation’s Health Care Snapshots page of their website and the data was entered into a spreadsheet to add the display of percentage increase for each country’s expenses between 1990 and 2003.
It is merely a random example of the big picture in health care. Hillary Rodham Clinton continues to speak about the benefits of her plan for all Americans. She does it in a way not unlike children who want their parents to get them a pet. All the child, in this case Hillary, can do is think of all the wonderful features of having a pet. Never giving equal time to the downside which in the case of pets is the feeding, grooming, bathing, care and attention and other tasks that come with pet ownership. Hillary on Health Care speaks to everything she believes you would want health care to be without paying attention to the downside. And the casual disregard for discussing the costs and how to pay for them is her biggest problem.
From data that is a few years old, the US spends about 2 trillion dollars on health care each year or about 15% of GDP. By now the $5600 dollar range of cost per person has probably exceeded $6000 or five hundred dollars per month. Like many other plans mentioned in the 2008 campaign, the focus is getting everyone insured and the claims by HRC in particular continues to suggest lower cost, quality health care for everyone. Forget about the options she mentions for keeping your insurance or using hers or whatever. The cost of health care and the quality of health care will not be solved by providing insurance coverage.
Of course the people and organizations she includes in her press releases will say this is a great thing. The Kaiser Family Foundation as well as all the health care ‘professionals’ she advertises will like the plan. They are all in the health care industry and any public funding of health care costs suits them just fine. Again, it does nothing to reduce the cost or improve the quality of health care. And if the cost of health care is not stabilized or reduced, the cost of Hillary’s program will rise every year like the table above and solve nothing.
Many items in the press release referenced here offer tax credits. That means you have to raise taxes elsewhere to offset the tax credit or the government’s checkbook takes a hit. Those are the kind of actions that increase budget deficits and the national debt plus put pressure on funds available for the private sector.
Another example of how things go in health care between the public and private sector is expressed in this excerpt from Health and Human Services. Private payers (primarily private health insurance and payments by individuals for co-pays, deductibles, and services not covered by insurance) funded more than half of national health expenditures in 2003, or $913.2 billion. The public sector funded $766 billion, with the Medicaid program funding 16 percent of aggregate health spending, or $267 billion, nearly equaling the 17 percent, $283 billion, spent by Medicare.
Hillary Rodham Clinton has mentioned a cost of $110 billion for her plan. The reference above from several years ago shows the public/private breakdown of paying for nearly two trillion in health care costs. Her plan will do nothing to lower costs. Her plan will do nothing for health care quality. Providing some people with health insurance will do nothing to lower the cost of health care itself. The people and the technology provide health care quality. It is not provided by health insurance.
The only reason the health care lobby, listed health care organizations or health care professionals like HillaryCare is that it provides public funds to pay for health care. Public funds in case you have forgotten are tax dollars from taxpayers. So either way the public pays for health care with or without HillaryCare. That won’t change. And the cost of that care or its quality will not change with HillaryCare either.
Lowering health care costs and raising the quality of health care provided is not being discussed. Providing health care insurance by shifting the cost of that insurance among private and public sources will solve nothing.
Stanford Matthews
MoreWhat.com

It is about time that someone focused on the fact that both parties are responsible for the mess in Washington and that ethics reform proposals in recent months have only served late night talk show hosts. Repairing the damage done as well as improving public opinion of government is no small task and cannot begin soon enough. While it is easier for Mitt Romney to approach this subject rather than his Senate rivals with their time in Washington, others like Giuliani and a few 2nd tier candidates are not officially connected to Washington and could just as easily have brought it up. It is a subject not frequently discussed and certainly not an issue that gets addressed. Score a few points for Romney in drawing attention to it.
Sure, give us the names. Bring up Larry Craig and pound individual examples rather than focus on the job of correcting the decay of government ethics. The witch hunt mentality may provide the single largest obstacle to cleaning up Washington. By placing true and effective methods in place to oversee government action with real transparency and enforcement the job could get done and the morbid curiosity of the public would be satisfied as those who stray from ethical standards would be held to account. The past and current effort of only placing blame as it relates to party has not been helpful. It ends up that no one is held to account except in extreme cases that benefit one part or the other and media revenues.
This is an open trackback linkfest. It happens every Monday, Wednesday and Friday. Each linkfest is open until the next one starts. Trackbacks will be on the frontpage in a post called MoreWhat Matters each Tuesday, Thursday and Sunday. The Secure the Borders theme is intended as a reminder to all for obvious reasons. If you have any suggestions, criticisms, questions or just feel the need to communicate, trackback or let us know in the comments. If you want to be added to Z’ Blogroll, register and/or inquire to make arrangements. The Honor Roll is reserved for blogs viewed as special by this blog’s owner.


In posts published here earlier a report indicated HillaryCare II was assembled by the same team from Hillary Care I. The report also indicated no significant overhaul of Hillary Care I, which failed, and the health care proposals from other Democratic candidates were based on this same model. A post here yesterday featured an appraisal from the Opnion Journal on Hillary Care I and II emphasizing the program will require a great deal of tax increases the details of which the Clinton campaign is not disclosing. Which is to say that the Dems health care proposals are essentially the same and will cost everyone dearly for limited health care provisions.



Faultline USA
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 1:30 pm Pledging Your Moral Stand for Immigrants Rights…
In the coming weeks and months your church may ask you to sign a pledge that you will take a public, moral stand for immigrants rights. If you oppose illegal immigration, are you ready for this faith challenge? Isnt it possible to stand for hum…
Pirate’s Cove » >>Americans Never Quit » Aaar! Talki Like A Pirate Day, Mateys!
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 1:40 pm […] Swag-posted to …… thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe. […]
Right Voices » Blog Archive » Linkfest:WaPa Calls Thompson A Liar For Stating That U.S. Has Shed More Blood Than Any Other Nation To Bring Liberty
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 1:49 pm […] Trackposted to ….. thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe. Bookmark to: […]
Rosemary’s Thoughts » Blog Archive » How NOT to move
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 3:05 pm […] These are the people whom I have trackbacked to: Blog @ MoreWhat.com, Faultline USA, Right Truth, The Meat Scale, The World According to Carl, Nuke’s News & Views, Cao’s Blog, Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker, Dumb Ox Daily News, Right Voices, Pursuing Holiness, The Yankee Sailor, CatSynth.com, […]
Big Dogs Weblog
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 3:31 pm Approval of Congress at All Time Low…
……
The World According To Carl
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 3:46 pm […] A full charge hello to readers …. Also a big thank you to Linkfest Haven Deluxe. […]
The World According To Carl
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 3:49 pm Strange Video: Familjen - “Det Snurrar I Min Skalle”…
This video is highly unusual. The footage comes from unknown (at least to me) film footage from the 1960’s (possibly) of a charismatic healing service most likely from somewhere in Europe. It’s spliced together in such a way to make it appear that …
Woman Honor Thyself
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 4:25 pm Lars Vilks “offends” the Kvetchers…
Hire your goon..here comes another toon!
……
DeMediacratic Nation
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 5:00 pm Wednesday Hero…
1st Lt. Forrest P. Ewens26 years old from Tonasket, Washing ……
Planck’s Constant
Says:
September 19th, 2007 at 5:45 pm A Salmagundi of Pirate Tales…
Ahoy, me hearties! ‘Tis Talk Like a Swashbuckler Tide again an’ I be havin’ a booty chest a merry yarns fer ye so let`s hoist th’ mizzen whilst I spin ye th’ important tales o’ th’ tide: …
The Amboy Times
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 12:40 am Cartoon Counter-Jihad…
I’m not a graphic novel reader myself, but this looks interesting. JW: The main character in The Infidel, the upcoming graphic novel by the ex-Muslim Bosch Fawstin, is another ex-Muslim cartoonist. The one who is a character in the book…
Planck’s Constant
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 1:01 am Chungs Close Shop after Roy Pearson Suit…
They have finally had enough, Soo Chung and her husband, Jin Nam Chung, owners of a dry cleaner who were sued for $54 million over a missing pair of pants, have sold the shop involved in the dispute. …
Gulf Coast Hurricane Tracker
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 2:09 am Avast - There be trouble a brewin’ in paradise…
Ahoy me hardy’s- the typhoon be approachin’ ye who lives along the Ole Gulf Coast. The land of lost treasures will be mighty stirred up over the next fortnight. Arggh - the rain be a coming from across La Floride and headin’ to the bounty in the lan…
Conservative Cat
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 2:20 am Important Safety Tip While Driving on Highway 53 North of the I-90 Tollway…
It turns out there is a junior league hockey team called The Chicago Force operating in the northwest suburbs. This organization has nothing to do with Bruce and Nate’s favorite football team, the Chicago Force. I’m mentioning this in case……
Shadowscope
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 4:16 am Thursday Thirteen #1…
Since I have ditched the Thursday Thongs meme here
I decided last week that I wanted to try and start participating regularly in the Thursday Thirteen. I was out of town last week and didn’t have the time to……
The World According To Carl
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 4:17 am […] Trackposted to …… Also thanks to Linkfest Haven Deluxe. […]
Leaning Straight Up
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 7:35 am Final Word: OJ…
They arrested him, but he made Bail. They charged him with everything but the fall of man.
He’s not going to escape this barring some miracle, so the Goldman’s will gloat.
My only real question?
Be honest: How man…
Republican National Convention Blog
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 1:06 pm Michael B. Mukasey Biography…
Michael Bernard Mukasey (born July 28, 1941). Mukasey attended the Ramaz School in Manhattan, graduating in 1959. His wife, Susan, was a teacher and headmistress of the lower school at Ramaz and both of their children (Marc and Jessica) attended the …..
Right Truth
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 2:44 pm Syria voted co-chairman of the IAEA, Israel’s on the agenda…
How crazy is this, “Syria voted co-chairman of the IAEA” — Two weeks after Israel’s alleged bombing raid in Syria, which some foreign reports said targeted North Korean nuclear material, the UN’s nuclear watchdog elected Syria as deputy chairman o…
Public Eye » Carter: Iran no threat
Says:
September 20th, 2007 at 4:36 pm […] Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL. « Google’s detailed streetscapes raise privacyconcerns […]